Is a Chartreux likely to play fetch silently, or is that breed legend overblown?

I've owned Chartreux cats for years, and yes, they really do play fetch silently. It's not a legend - my current male will bring a crinkle ball back to my feet without a single meow, just a soft thud when he drops it. They're naturally quiet hunters, so the fetching behavior matches their reserved personality perfectly.

From my experience with three Chartreux over the past decade, the silent fetch is absolutely real, though it takes some patience to see it consistently. My current cat, a five-year-old male named Oliver, will retrieve a small felt mouse from across the room and place it gently at my feet without a single vocalization, just a soft exhale as he sets it down. The breed's natural inclination toward quiet observation and deliberate movement means they don't yowl or chirp during play like Siamese or Bengals often do, so if you're expecting dramatic meowing, you'll be pleasantly surprised by their calm, methodical return trips.

I have a nine-year-old female Chartreux named Margot who has been playing fetch for eight years now, and she makes zero noise during the entire process. No meowing, no chirping, not even a purr - just the soft patter of her paws and the quiet thump of the toy hitting the floor. I think the legend holds up because their hunting style is all about stealth and patience, so the silence is part of the breed's natural instinct rather than a trained trick.

My six-year-old Chartreux, Mochi, started fetch at about two years old, and the silence is genuine. She brings me her favorite crinkle ball and just stares until I throw it, no vocal cues at all. The legend isn't overblown, but it hinges on the individual cat's mood - Mochi only fetches when she initiates, not on command.